The Kick | Issue 78
Somewhere this month an owner averaging eight leads a month is picking fonts for a new belt patch, and the patches are going to look incredible.
Down the street, another owner is migrating to his fourth CRM in five years and telling his staff this is the one that finally fixes retention.

HOW TO DETERMINE WHAT TO FIX FIRST IN YOUR MARTIAL ARTS SCHOOL
The Most Dangerous Box Is The One That Feels Like Progress
Every problem you work on in your school lands in one of four boxes. You can solve the right problem the right way, the right problem the wrong way, the wrong problem the wrong way, or the wrong problem the right way.
Right problem, wrong way is the owner who knows he needs more students and spends six weeks putting flyers on windshields. He picked the correct target and the weakest lever in the building. He feels the failure fast, and fast failure at least teaches you something.
Wrong problem, wrong way is an owner whose school I managed years ago. Every problem in that building sent him back to the curriculum. Enrollment dipped, he rewrote it. Retention slipped, he rewrote it again. He changed it so many times the upper belts were ready to quit, because every time they learned it, it moved. The curriculum was never the issue, and every rewrite stacked a new problem on top of the old ones.
The one I worry about is wrong problem, right way. Picture a front desk role that has burned through three people. Each one underperformed, so each one got let go, which on paper is exactly what you do with someone who is not performing. The new hire shows up, the energy comes back, and three months later you are writing the same job post. The real problem lives in the onboarding and the systems nobody built, and firing people is a very competent way to never touch it.
That box is dangerous because it feels like work getting done. Your calendar agrees with you and your bank account disagrees. When the same problem comes back after you have solved it three times, you have been solving the wrong one.

Some Problems Are Cheaper To Keep Than To Fix
Before I touch anything in the business I run three questions. What does this problem cost me per year. What does the fix cost in dollars and hours. How long until the fix pays me back.
I was talking with an accountant recently whose employee wanted to automate four hours of manual work every Friday. The employee makes $70,000 a year. Four hours out of a forty hour week is ten percent of the job, which makes it a $7,000 a year problem. When they priced out building the automation, time and money all in, it came to $70,000.
That fix takes ten years to break even, and the right answer is to do nothing.
Owners almost never treat doing nothing as a legitimate option. It is often the best one, because leaving a small problem alone is what frees you to go after the big one. When you run the math on a lot of the fixes your team asks for, you find you are paying to remove work somebody would rather avoid. If the math does not work, either the work gets done or the wrong person is in the seat.
Run the same math on the projects sitting on your desk right now. I talked to an owner averaging six to ten leads a month who wanted to talk about redesigning the interior of his school. I have watched schools redesign belt patches in a month with zero new leads. I have watched more schools switch CRMs than I can count. I am unhappy with my own CRM right now and I am staying put, because it is not costing me enough to earn that much of my attention.
Your Funnel Has One Number That Matters This Quarter
Think about a deadlift. Your back can pull 500 pounds and so can your legs, but your grip gives out at 300, so 300 is your max. Train the grip and the whole lift goes up. Every other muscle was already waiting on it.
Your enrollment funnel works the same way. Say you get 1,000 leads, book 75 percent of them, half of the booked show up, and you enroll 8 percent of the people who show. That is 30 new students.
Now imagine you could improve one stage by five points. Booking goes from 75 to 80 percent and you get two more students. Show rate goes from 50 to 55 percent and you get three more. Close rate goes from 8 to 13 percent and you get nineteen more.
That is nineteen students against two or three. In that school I am leaving lead generation alone, and I am leaving the show rate alone even though 50 percent is ugly. Every hour goes into the intro and the close until it stops being the weakest link, and then I go find the next one.
A fitness studio once told me they needed 500 leads a month. They were enrolling about a quarter of the people who showed up, and a big chunk of their booked appointments were ghosting them. Five hundred leads would have made their real problem more expensive and changed nothing else.
You cannot do this math on numbers you are guessing at. If you have to estimate your booking rate, your show rate, and your close rate, you will land in one of the three wrong boxes more often than the right one.

Retention Breaks On A Specific Date
Most owners treat attrition like one big leak. They are sitting in a boat with a dozen small holes and one massive one, duct taping as fast as they can, and the big hole keeps winning.
In most schools I look at, the massive hole sits in one of two places. It is the first 90 days, or it is right before sparring starts. Pull your cancellations and sort them by how long each family had been with you. The pattern usually jumps off the screen.
We had our own version of this. We run twelve week seasons, and even with a 90 day onboarding we were losing new families inside three months. When I dug into the data, the families leaving had mostly started in weeks seven through twelve of a season. They were not ready for the graduation at week twelve, so their first belt was another three months away, and they went their entire first 90 days without a single win.
That is why we built a milestone system that rewards class counts alongside belts. The fix itself was small. Finding it required knowing exactly which week the boat was taking on water.
The Constraint Hides Two Steps Behind The Complaint
The problems owners bring me are usually symptoms sitting on top of the real constraint.
I can't find great instructors. Why? I can't afford A players on these margins. Then raise prices. I can't, because I'm already enrolling too few people.
Most owners hearing that first sentence go rebuild their instructor development program. In this school that fixes nothing. The great instructors are out there, and he cannot afford them. The constraint is the sales motion. Enroll more and you can price better. Price better and your margins open up. Wider margins let you pay the best people, and the best people are what a premium brand is made of.
I call that fixing it forward, and it is the reason I can recruit people who could be running their own businesses. We have the margins to offer health insurance, unlimited PTO for full timers, and more per hour than anyone else in this industry pays. None of that would exist if I had spent the last three years rebuilding an instructor program while enrollment sat broken.
Reports Will Never Tell You What The Floor Will
I have been back in my school every single day lately, and it has reminded me how much a dashboard can hide.
Our upgrade program had twenty kids on it out of roughly 250 students. Nothing in our reports flagged that as a crisis. Standing on the floor, I could see why within a day. Nobody on the team was walking up to a kid and telling him he would be great on Legends. The system existed, nobody was running it, and the one person who would have noticed was out of the building.
At graduation last week we invited ten kids. Parents lined up afterward asking how to get their child in. We are inviting ten more every month through December, which adds roughly $4,000 a month in recurring revenue by the end of the year, from a program we already had.
Use AI to watch your numbers. I do, and it saves me hours every week. Let it help you run the business while your own eyes stay on the floor, because the constraint costing you the most is usually the one your reports were never built to see.
"The problem you keep solving is usually the one you are best at, which is exactly why solving it never moves the business."

WORTH STEALING - THE WEAKEST LINK FINDER
Most owners know their monthly revenue and their student count and almost nothing in between. That blind spot is where every wrong problem project gets born, because without the stage by stage numbers you end up working on whatever feels loudest.
This prompt takes your real numbers, runs the five point test on every stage of your funnel, finds where your cancellations cluster, and then grades the three projects currently eating your week. Paste it into Claude or ChatGPT and answer as it asks.
You are an operations analyst for a martial arts school. Your job is to find the single weakest link in my business using my real numbers, then tell me honestly whether what I am working on right now is aimed at it.
Ask me these questions ONE AT A TIME. Wait for my answer before moving on. Do not summarize between questions.
1. How many new leads did you get last month? 2. How many of those booked an intro or trial? 3. How many of the booked actually showed up? 4. How many of the ones who showed enrolled? 5. How many active students do you have, and how many cancelled last month? 6. For your last 10 to 20 cancellations, how long had each family been enrolled? Rough months are fine. 7. What is your average monthly tuition? 8. List the three projects taking the most of your time right now. For each one, give a rough guess of what it will cost to finish in dollars and hours.
Then produce this output.
FUNNEL: each stage as a percentage, laid out in order from lead to enrollment.
FIVE POINT TEST: for booking rate, show rate, and close rate, calculate how many additional enrollments per month I would get from a five percentage point improvement in that stage alone, holding everything else equal. Show the math.
RETENTION READ: tell me where my cancellations cluster by tenure and what that suggests is breaking.
THE WEAKEST LINK: name the one stage that deserves my next 90 days of focus, in one sentence.
PROJECT VERDICT: place each of my three projects in one box: right problem right way, right problem wrong way, wrong problem wrong way, or wrong problem right way. Estimate what the underlying problem costs me per year and the payback period on the fix. If the honest answer is to stop or do nothing, say so.
Be blunt. Do not reassure me. If any of my numbers are missing or look wrong, tell me what to go measure before I trust the result.
Run it on the first Monday of every month with fresh numbers. When the weakest link moves, your focus moves with it, and any project that earns the same bad verdict two months in a row gets cut. For the brave version, set a 15 minute timer on your phone for one week, write down what you did every time it goes off, and paste that log in as question nine. Most owners find out their week went somewhere very different from where they thought it went.

SEEN IN THE WILD
THE DROP OFF PARENT IS THE EASIEST FAMILY TO WIN BACK.
Adam Kifer with a quick tactic for pulling drop off parents back into their kid's training. Last week's issue called them your quietest cancellation, and this is the fix in under a minute. Run it before your next class, because the parent idling in the pickup line tonight is already deciding what this is worth.
YOUR STUDENTS ARE BORROWING SOMEBODY'S MINDSET EITHER WAY.
OpusAthletic on installing the right athlete mindset in your students. Every kid on your mat is picking up a way of thinking from somewhere, and if your mat chats get written the night before, that somewhere is probably YouTube. Save this one and pull a month of material out of it.
PEOPLE BUY THE SAME WAY THEY DID WHEN YOUR SCHOOL OPENED.
A great download on the psychology of buying, and none of it has changed in decades. Plenty of owners in this industry rebuild their intro offer every season chasing the newest tactic, while the reasons a parent says yes have stayed exactly where they were. Watch it before you touch your intro script again, then ask yourself whether the script was ever the weakest link.

THE STAT
43%
In 2018 Harvard Business School professors Michael Porter and Nitin Nohria published a study of 27 CEOs whose assistants logged how they spent their time in 15 minute increments for 13 weeks. Across roughly 60,000 hours, those CEOs spent an average of 43 percent of their work time on activities that advanced their own agendas.
These are people with chiefs of staff, executive assistants, and entire departments built to absorb the stuff that eats your week. With all of that, less than half their time went to what they had decided mattered most, and about 36 percent went to reacting to issues as they unfolded. Most people read the study as proof that executives are busy. The real lesson is gravity. Whatever is loudest takes the time by default, even from people who have spent millions defending against it.
Then there is the question of whether you would even notice. Gloria Mark at UC Irvine has been measuring how long people hold their attention on a single screen since 2004. It was about two and a half minutes then, 75 seconds by 2012, and around 47 seconds in her more recent work. In one of her studies, people estimated they switched tasks about 15 times an hour, and observation showed more than 30. The CEOs had assistants keeping score. Mark's subjects were keeping their own, and they missed by half.
Nobody is logging your week. The Tuesday afternoon you spent comparing CRM demos is filed in your memory as working on retention, and the intro your front desk fumbled at 4:30 that same day is filed nowhere. If CEOs with full staffs top out at 43 percent, the number for an owner who also teaches the 5:00 class is lower, and right now the only person grading it is you.
Sources: Porter and Nohria, "How CEOs Manage Time," Harvard Business Review; Gloria Mark interview, Dropbox Blog, "Behold, the 47-second workday"

CLOSING THOUGHT
Every one of us has a problem we are good at solving, and for a lot of us it is the curriculum or the website. When the business gets uncomfortable, that is where our hands go, because working on it feels like being useful. The real constraint is almost always sitting somewhere we feel clumsy, which is exactly how it has managed to sit there untouched for so long. The owners who finally break through are usually the ones who agreed to spend a quarter feeling bad at the one thing that actually matters.

